CJEI presents CANNABIS in the CITY
Episode 2 | The Ghost in the Room: How Past Convictions Still Haunt Our Communities
Even after the sentence ends, the consequences don’t. From job interviews to housing to family decisions, past convictions linger like a ghost — shaping futures, closing doors, and weighing heavy on minds and communities.
In this episode, Sean and Jeff break down the REAL impact of old records, the racial disparities behind them, and how New York’s MRTA was designed to bring justice… if people know how to use it.
Transcript:
*Disclaimer: This transcript was auto-generated and may contain errors.
View transcript.
[00:00:00] Did you know that in New York it’s
[00:00:02] illegal to drive after smoking weed?
[00:00:04] Many believe recreational cannabis is a
[00:00:07] free pass, but that’s not true. Even if
[00:00:10] you only have a little green in your
[00:00:12] system, you can be pulled over and face
[00:00:14] serious charges. And it gets worse. If
[00:00:17] someone is smoking in your car, you
[00:00:18] [music] can still get a ticket. Even if
[00:00:20] you weren’t the one lighting up, police
[00:00:23] are cracking down on impaired driving to
[00:00:25] keep roads safe. So, if you enjoy
[00:00:27] cannabis, remember, never drive high.
[00:00:30] It’s not just dangerous, it’s illegal.
[00:00:33] Your rights [music] are important, but
[00:00:35] so are your responsibilities. Always opt
[00:00:37] for a sober ride or use designated
[00:00:40] drivers. Knowledge [music] is power,
[00:00:42] especially with the laws changing all
[00:00:43] the time. Stay informed, stay safe, and
[00:00:46] drive responsibly in the city that never
[00:00:48] sleeps.
[00:00:56] >> [cheering]
[00:01:01] >> Welcome back to Justice and Cannabis.
[00:01:04] I’m your host and co-le director of the
[00:01:07] Justice Lab, Sean Farrow. And with me,
[00:01:09] as always, is my co-host and co-le
[00:01:13] director, Jeff Hoffman.
[00:01:15] So this segment we’re going to talk
[00:01:17] about the ghost in the room. How past
[00:01:20] convictions still haunt so many of us.
[00:01:25] The Marijuana Regulation and Taxation
[00:01:27] Act or MARTA promised justice for
[00:01:32] so many people. But for tens of
[00:01:34] thousands of New Yorkers, a past
[00:01:36] conviction isn’t gone when the sentence
[00:01:38] ends. It lingers like a ghost, haunting
[00:01:41] every job interview, every apartment
[00:01:44] application, and even decisions about
[00:01:47] your children. Today, we’re confronting
[00:01:49] the ghost, exploring how it lingers, how
[00:01:52] it haunts, and how we could finally lay
[00:01:54] it to rest. First, we’re going to start
[00:01:56] with the personal impact and everyday
[00:01:59] consequences. Jeff, you know from time
[00:02:01] and time again with so many of our
[00:02:03] clients, so many New Yorkers when they
[00:02:05] go to do that job application or that
[00:02:08] house application, yeah, they’re not
[00:02:10] supposed to talk about it, the landlord
[00:02:12] or the the supervisor, but yet again,
[00:02:14] time and time again, these folks are
[00:02:16] just turned away. Talk to us a little
[00:02:19] bit about the impact that these
[00:02:21] convictions, misdemeanor, or felonies
[00:02:23] are having on New Yorkers as they’re
[00:02:24] trying to make their life better and
[00:02:27] trying to move forward. So this is
[00:02:28] exactly correct, Sean, and it’s one of
[00:02:30] the reasons why the legislature
[00:02:32] implemented the expungement provision in
[00:02:35] the law. We know it’s a fact. This is
[00:02:38] not anecdotal. We know it’s a fact that
[00:02:41] a person’s income is significantly
[00:02:44] impacted by having these convictions.
[00:02:46] The Brennan Center has said that
[00:02:49] misdemeanor convictions can result in up
[00:02:51] to a 15% decrease in a person’s
[00:02:54] earnings. And even worse, a felony can
[00:02:57] get up to 20% decrease in a person’s
[00:03:00] earnings. We’re talking about billions
[00:03:02] and billions of dollars, perhaps over 10
[00:03:05] billion dollars in the state of New York
[00:03:07] that people are missing out on in their
[00:03:10] employment opportunities due to these
[00:03:12] issues. And then the housing
[00:03:13] opportunities is quite simple. If you
[00:03:15] don’t have a place to live, it’s very
[00:03:16] difficult for you to do anything. Yeah.
[00:03:18] >> In your life. And so these are the
[00:03:21] ramifications
[00:03:22] of having a cannabis conviction that the
[00:03:25] cannabis law is looking to rectify.
[00:03:27] >> And we talked about it on our last
[00:03:29] segment how misdemeanor convictions are
[00:03:31] supposed to be automatically expunged.
[00:03:34] But how many people actually know that?
[00:03:37] How many people are actually
[00:03:38] experiencing that day to day?
[00:03:40] >> So in my experience and in your
[00:03:42] experience from have having helped a lot
[00:03:44] of folks with this, no one knows about
[00:03:46] it, right? The law did not require that
[00:03:49] the state reach out to individuals that
[00:03:52] had these convictions. And so
[00:03:54] unfortunately what happens is people do
[00:03:56] not know that their convictions have
[00:03:58] been expunged in the case of the
[00:04:00] misdemeanors. So unfortunately in the
[00:04:03] cases when they apply for jobs or apply
[00:04:06] for housing and the landlord or the
[00:04:08] employer incorrectly ask them about
[00:04:11] their conviction status these
[00:04:13] individuals don’t know that their
[00:04:14] convictions are no longer in effect and
[00:04:17] unfortunately will then answer those
[00:04:18] questions yes as we like to say check
[00:04:21] the yes box. Yeah. And what makes it
[00:04:23] even worse is that if if we escalate it
[00:04:26] just a little bit to felony convictions,
[00:04:28] right?
[00:04:28] >> So many of the landlords, so many of the
[00:04:31] uh managers at work, they’re not looking
[00:04:33] to see whether this was a cannabis
[00:04:35] conviction or not. They just see felony
[00:04:36] and it’s automatic no. To your point,
[00:04:39] even though they’re not supposed to. So
[00:04:41] what are folks supposed to do when they
[00:04:42] have a felony conviction and every time
[00:04:44] they go for an application, it’s popping
[00:04:47] up.
[00:04:47] >> Sure. So that is again one of the things
[00:04:50] that the Justice Lab does. It’s one of
[00:04:52] the core services that we offer to
[00:04:54] people that come to the Justice Lab. And
[00:04:56] again, this is a free service. We help
[00:04:58] you look at your record. We help
[00:05:01] determine what are the things that may
[00:05:03] impact you. Do you have cannabis
[00:05:05] convictions that we can get completely
[00:05:07] expunged or do you have other convictions
[00:05:10] where we can get you one of the many
[00:05:12] certificates that perhaps would allow
[00:05:14] you to vote again or a certificate of
[00:05:16] good conduct? all all these kinds of
[00:05:18] relief that you can get from that. And
[00:05:21] in addition, it is now possible to get
[00:05:23] your records sealed. In fact, there’s a
[00:05:25] law that several years from now is going
[00:05:27] to hopefully seal all convictions that
[00:05:30] are over a certain age. But right now,
[00:05:32] we still have to actively deal with
[00:05:34] this. And unfortunately, once again, the
[00:05:36] law did not require the state to notify
[00:05:39] people that have these convictions. Hey,
[00:05:42] the law now allows in the case of the
[00:05:44] cannabis convictions for this to be
[00:05:46] expunged and if you have some other type
[00:05:48] of conviction, there are pathways to
[00:05:51] ameliate the issues that you are facing
[00:05:54] due to having that conviction.
[00:05:56] >> So the two things you just said there I
[00:05:57] thought was fantastic. So one is we have
[00:05:59] to be proactive, right? there there is
[00:06:02] an actual energy and emotion that we
[00:06:04] need to put in place to make sure that
[00:06:06] your automatic expungements have
[00:06:08] happened as well as the felony
[00:06:10] convictions that we’re actually tackling
[00:06:11] them. What I think is also important
[00:06:13] here and we didn’t touch upon it on the
[00:06:15] last show but I want to touch upon it
[00:06:16] now is who is this really affecting the
[00:06:19] most. Right? We know that this cannabis
[00:06:22] uh prohibition is racist but how racist
[00:06:25] are we talking about? What I saw from my
[00:06:28] research here is that 5 7 times and 3.7
[00:06:33] times more likely are black and brown
[00:06:36] people to be convicted, not just
[00:06:38] arrested, convicted than their white
[00:06:41] peers here. And that just screams to me.
[00:06:45] So, we see that this is affecting our
[00:06:47] people here and the people that we want
[00:06:49] to help. What must we do to just push
[00:06:53] them or implore them in order to do more
[00:06:56] and become active and take advantage of
[00:06:58] what we can do here at the Justice Lab?
[00:07:00] So that’s part of what we’re doing here
[00:07:01] today. We’re trying to get the message
[00:07:03] out through all of the channels that we
[00:07:04] have access to, including television,
[00:07:08] through events that Cannabis Justice and
[00:07:10] Equity Initiative puts on where we try
[00:07:13] to get the message out. We have all
[00:07:15] kinds of outreach that we’re beginning
[00:07:16] to do with local government. As we know,
[00:07:19] New York City was the epicenter of this.
[00:07:22] New York City was by far the worst city
[00:07:26] on planet Earth for anti-cannabis
[00:07:28] enforcement,
[00:07:30] >> mostly, as you’ve already noted, against
[00:07:32] black and brown folks.
[00:07:33] >> Yeah.
[00:07:33] >> And we’ve been working with the city
[00:07:35] government here in particular to get
[00:07:37] this message out to be involved in the
[00:07:39] events that we’re in. We are working
[00:07:41] with legal aid and other uh uh legal
[00:07:45] focused groups that would have already
[00:07:47] interacted with these individuals
[00:07:48] perhaps helped them with their original
[00:07:50] cases and then getting a pipeline of the
[00:07:53] individuals that we had kind of hoped
[00:07:55] that the state would notify about these
[00:07:57] issues. But again, starting to create
[00:07:59] those pipelines where the organizations
[00:08:02] that have the touch points with
[00:08:04] individuals that are impacted by this,
[00:08:06] getting the message out that if you have
[00:08:08] a misdemeanor cannabis conviction, you
[00:08:10] need to get your certificate of
[00:08:11] disposition to make sure that it’s been
[00:08:13] cleared up. And if you have a felony,
[00:08:15] you need to reach out to us at the
[00:08:17] Cannabis Justice and Equity Initiative
[00:08:19] so that we can assist you doing the
[00:08:21] things that you have to do in court in
[00:08:23] order to get that felony conviction
[00:08:25] expunged. And that’s for free, right?
[00:08:27] >> That is 100% free. That’s what we That
[00:08:29] is what we do here at the Cannabis
[00:08:32] Justice and Equity Initiative.
[00:08:34] >> And what I want folks to understand is
[00:08:36] that it doesn’t just affect, you know,
[00:08:38] your job. If any job requires a license,
[00:08:40] it affects that. It affects your housing
[00:08:42] as we talked about, but it also affects
[00:08:44] as we know especially these times. It
[00:08:46] affects your immigration status. It can
[00:08:48] affect your ability to travel. Can you
[00:08:49] come back to the United States? So, this
[00:08:53] has a monstrous ripple effect that
[00:08:55] people need to make sure that they are
[00:08:57] locked into and addressing as soon as
[00:08:59] possible. And please reach out to Jeff
[00:09:01] and I to make sure that we’re doing
[00:09:03] everything possible to help you move
[00:09:06] forward without this ghost just haunting
[00:09:07] you at every turn. And I just want to
[00:09:10] make sure that we finish on this last
[00:09:11] point. All the work that we’ve done is
[00:09:14] not without some success and some hope,
[00:09:16] right? We have been successful in
[00:09:18] helping people clear their records. Can
[00:09:20] you share a story with us on that? Sure.
[00:09:21] So, probably the biggest case that we’ve
[00:09:24] dealt with, there’s an individual out in
[00:09:27] Western New York who after he served his
[00:09:29] time for his cannabis conviction, uh
[00:09:33] finished getting his degree, graduated
[00:09:35] with a master’s degree with honors, uh
[00:09:38] became an award-winning uh school
[00:09:40] psychologist, but unfortunately, he was
[00:09:42] not able to uh continue to get
[00:09:45] promotions within his career. And in
[00:09:47] fact, we got letters from puditive
[00:09:49] employers that said, “We know we offered
[00:09:52] you a job. We then found out about your
[00:09:54] conviction status, and now we have to
[00:09:56] retract that employment opportunity.”
[00:09:58] >> And unfortunately, as we’ve seen in many
[00:10:01] parts of the state, the judge that heard
[00:10:04] his case about expungement initially
[00:10:06] before he came to us just rejected it.
[00:10:08] Didn’t even basically read what
[00:10:10] >> didn’t do anything with the law.
[00:10:11] [laughter]
[00:10:11] >> Didn’t do anything based on law. just
[00:10:13] basically made up his own procedure and
[00:10:16] rejected the expungement. We then worked
[00:10:19] with this individual and refiled uh for
[00:10:23] reargument in front of the in front of
[00:10:25] the judge. Um, initially it looked like
[00:10:27] we were actually going to have to appeal
[00:10:28] his case to a higher court and then the
[00:10:32] assistant district attorney who was
[00:10:33] involved in the case kind of realized,
[00:10:36] hey, we’ve got a loser here and if we
[00:10:39] have to go appeal this, it’s going to
[00:10:41] look really bad for us and look really
[00:10:43] bad for the judge. So, we were able to
[00:10:45] convince them to basically give us
[00:10:47] everything we wanted. We got the judge
[00:10:49] on the record saying that yes, this
[00:10:52] individual’s conviction should be
[00:10:54] completely expunged with no substitution
[00:10:56] of a lower crime. And we got the uh
[00:10:59] district attorney to actually get on the
[00:11:01] record and say, “We didn’t do it right
[00:11:03] originally. We are now doing it right.
[00:11:06] This is the correct procedure for how
[00:11:08] these cases have to be dealt with.” And
[00:11:10] we now have that on the record so that
[00:11:11] we can use it in further cases when
[00:11:14] perhaps more conservative judges don’t
[00:11:16] want to expunge these convictions just
[00:11:18] because they don’t think it should be in
[00:11:20] direct contravention to what the law
[00:11:22] says.
[00:11:22] >> Well said here and we’ll kind of end on
[00:11:24] this point. Clearing your record, it
[00:11:27] it’s not always easy, but we’re here to
[00:11:29] help. And it goes beyond one person in
[00:11:32] terms of what effect it has on you and
[00:11:34] the effect it has on your family and
[00:11:36] your community. the record. Clearing the
[00:11:38] record not only repairs your
[00:11:40] reputations, but it opens doors to jobs,
[00:11:43] licenses, and opportunities, and most
[00:11:45] importantly, to your chance to fully
[00:11:47] participate in society again. A true
[00:11:49] fresh start, and we do it for free. So,
[00:11:52] the call to action is simple. Your past
[00:11:54] doesn’t have to haunt your future. The
[00:11:56] ghost can be removed, and there’s a path
[00:11:58] forward. We’ll guide you every step of
[00:12:00] the way for free.
[00:12:02] >> That’s it, my friend. Let’s get it done.
[00:12:04] >> Let’s get it done. Back to you.
